Gaylord Provides Kitchen Exhaust Hoods
with
Fire Dampers That
Automatically Reset
After a Fire system Discharge
There are two schools of thought when it comes to fire dampers
in kitchen exhaust hoods.
The first school of thought says that fire dampers should
not be not allowed because once they shut there is no longer
any smoke evacuation from the kitchen exhaust hood and the
only thing that matters is smoke evacuation.
The second school of thought is that the fire damper prevents
the fire from migrating out of the kitchen into the duct
work and potentially up on to the roof. Remember that Fire
Marshall’s are always looking at worst case. Even though
ducts are supposed to be cleaned regularly they often are
not and this leads to high fuel loads with lots of oxygen
available. The only thing missing is heat, which is just
down stream from the duct. Once we get all three elements
of the fire triangle in place we can have a dramatic fire.
Duct shafts are helpful, but not always successful, in containing
a fire with a high fuel and load and lots of oxygen. Let
me describe a worst case scenario. If the fire in the kitchen
is a flash fire at the cooking appliance the cooking staff
may be unaware that it has moved into the duct and beyond
the suppression system in the hood. This fire may then get
out of the shaft or up on to the roof where it may go unnoticed
for some period of time greatly increasing the damage to
the structure and/or involving other parts of the building
and putting more people at risk, especially in multistory
occupancies
Gaylord makes hoods with and without dampers. But overall
are advocates of fire dampers in for the following reasons
. One, the quantity smoke that a kitchen fire creates. This
amount of smoke is way beyond the capability of any kitchen
exhaust fan evacuate in any short amount of time. Two, A
kitchen exhaust hood is designed for the minimum amount of
exhaust in order to reduce the energy consumption for heating,
cooling and moving the air. In our lab we have witnessed
over 800 fryer fires and hundreds of over types kitchen fires
during our testing of hoods to UL710 and water spray nozzles
to UL 199E. This has demonstrated to us that the above is
true. In addition we believe that fire dampers in kitchen
exhaust hoods can reduce the spread of the fire and potentially
accelerate the activation of a suppression system by increasing
the build up of heat in the hood. This will reduce the time
it takes to activate the system and put out the fire before
it gets larger, creating more smoke, heat and thus greater
risk to the building. In addition, other systems in the building
use fire and smoke dampers to contain a fire in a specific
location or to prevent it from migrating to other parts of
the building, why wouldn’t the same logic apply here?
Because of this Gaylord Industries developed hoods that
can provide the best of both worlds. By using fire dampers
that are thermostatically actuated with spring return electric
motors we believe we reduce the risk of fire migrating into
the duct and provide smoke evacuation when ever there is
no risk to the duct. When the hoods are installed and wired
per our instructions the following scenarios can occur.
- A fire starts under the hood.
The 250 degrees stat.
senses the fire and the damper closes, the exhaust and
supply fan shut off
This rapidly builds heat in the hood,
which sets off the suppression system.
Once the temperature
in the duct collar drops below 250 F the damper starts
to open and the exhaust fan will come on, providing smoke
evacuation. The supply fan stays off.
- A fire starts under the hood
The suppression system activates.
But, the heat build up has exceeded 250F at the duct collar.
The fire damper will close, exhaust fan off, supply off,
all energy sources off under the hood. Once the temperature
drops below 250 F at the duct collar the damper opens, exhaust
fan starts and supply stays off. If the temperature never
exceeds 250 F at the duct collar then the exhaust fan will
stay on or be started if it is off.
Because we use an electric damper that is thermostatically
activated. The damper can open and close as many times as
needed, if, for any reason the temperature in the hood duct
collar exceeds 250 F. This is truly the best of both worlds.
Smoke evacuation when ever there is no risk of spreading
fire to the duct and damper activation when ever there is
risk to spreading fire to the duct work.
We at Gaylord Industries believe that this is the safest,
most effective, system available today. Below is a matrix
showing the damper position, fan status and fire system status
for reference.
|
Normal Operation |
Thermostat Activated |
Fire system Activated,
and thermostat Not Activated |
Fire system activated
and thermostat Activated |
Fire system activated and
thermostat Below 250F |
Exhaust Fan |
ON |
OFF |
ON |
OFF |
ON |
Supply Fan |
ON |
OFF |
OFF |
OFF |
OFF |
Damper |
OPEN |
CLOSED |
OPEN |
CLOSED |
OPEN |
|