Recent industry testing now proves
that typical baffle filters are only about 15% to 30% efficient.
This testing sponsored by ASHRAE's Technical Committee TC
5.10 for Kitchen Ventilation was conducted under Research
Project #1151 proving that typical baffle filters are very
inefficient in capturing grease particles under 10 microns.
New two stage filters are being marketed as being as much
as 80% efficient.
For years, the capture efficiency of baffle grease filters
had been marketed to the industry as being as high as 95%
efficient. We all accepted that fact. We now know this to
be fact, but with a vitally important distinction. It only
applies to larger particles of grease greater than 10 micron
size. The test formerly used was developed by the U.S. Navy
and did not take into account smaller grease particles below
10 microns in size. The fact is that the majority of grease
particles from normal commercial cooking operations are predictably
under 10 microns.
Some caution needs to be taken as these new dual stage
filters significantly increase static pressure resistance
and may not readily replace typical baffle filters in marginally
operating systems.
The first entry was developed by Greenheck and named the
Grease Grabber. It is a combination of a newly designed front
filter called the Grease-XD-Tractor and a rear or second
stage filled with a ½" bead bed. The front face
has a new look that employs air inlets at the top and bottom
only. Together they become the Grease Grabber model. Greenheck
has been successfully producing and marketing this new line
of filters for approximately three years. Grease Grabber
is a UL listed device in accordance with UL 1046.
A second manufacturer is just introducing their Grease-Stop
Combo filter. This filter uses a familiar looking baffle
filter in front with a removable second stage that snaps
in place on the rear. The second stage employs porous ceramic
beads that capture and store or hold the grease molecules.
The manufacturer, Captrate claims a 70% capture rate for
grease molecules down to one micron. Captrate has ETL listing
is in accordance with UL 1046.
These new designs reportedly trap significantly more grease
emissions and represent a major step forward in reducing
the amount of grease passing through the filters into the
plenum, duct work and fan. It should be noted that filters
do not remove vapors, only particulates most often referred
to as grease particles.
Contact either manufacturer at their respective websites
for greater detail, testing information and charts. Contact
Greenheck at www.greenheck.com and
Captrate at www.captrate.com. |